Repost: Elmic Compact modifications (repost from old forum)

Button pushers
Post Reply
Pchristy
Posts: 417
Joined: 16 Feb 2018, 13:57
Location: South Devon, UK

Repost: Elmic Compact modifications (repost from old forum)

Post by Pchristy »

The Compact was the last - and arguable the best - escapement made by Elmic. It was small, fast and generally reliable. However it did have a quirk, which was a feature of its times, and a few minutes work with a soldering iron can improve its reliability significantly!

At the time of its introduction, most of us were using 225mAH DEACs as our battery supplies. An escapement typically drew nearly 500 mA when activated (coil impedance typically in the 8-10 Ohm range). Elmic sought to reduce the current consumption by switching in a series resistor (around 10 Ohms) once the armature had pulled in. The theory was that it took less current to hold the armature in than to pull it in in the first place.

This worked quite well when the escapement was new. But as it became older and dirtier, the connection between the wiper and circuit board became poorer, with the result that the resistor was effectively in circuit all the time! This resulted in the failure of the armature to "pull in" when required, and the occasional fly-away!

Also, later versions had solder tags riveted to the PCB, to make connections easier. Unfortunately, with time, these rivets came loose, leading to another point of failure.

Fortunately the solution to these issues is simple. Modern systems tend to use "AAA" Eneloops, or even small LiPos for power, so current consumption is no longer an issue. This means we can eliminate the power saving resistor. We can also solder the rivets to the board (if the escapement has them, early ones did not), eliminating another issue.

Here's how:

ImageCompact_1 by Peter Christy, on Flickr

First remove the plastic rotor by simply unscrewing it from the "hook". Watch out for the washer between the rotor and the PCB.

ImageCompact_2 by Peter Christy, on Flickr

Next, solder the rivets to the PCB (the third tag is for the "quick-blip" function):

ImageCompact_3 by Peter Christy, on Flickr

Finally solder a bridge across the resistor, shorting it out:

ImageCompact_4 by Peter Christy, on Flickr

Re-assemble the rotor onto the "hook" shaft - not forgetting the washer!

You will now have a much more reliable Compact escapement!

Have fun!

--
Pete
HenkB
Posts: 44
Joined: 01 Feb 2019, 11:19
Location: Harderwijk, The Netherlands

Re: Elmic Compact modifications (repost from old forum)

Post by HenkB »

Thanks for sharing the improvements. Makes sense.
Post Reply